Attahiyyatu reading at the end of the Prophet Muhammad turned to finger pointing. So amalati circumcision. Simply on the basis of authentic traditions proved to be pointing fingers. Do not move a finger. He said with a wave of the finger, the statement is not true.?
Hazrat Amir Abdullah bin Jubair narrated from his father that, he said, the Prophet peace be upon him to sit for the tashahhud reading, the right hand on the right thigh and put his left hand on left thigh. He was martyred by finger pointing. The median time to connect with the thumb and left palm [left] knee kept. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1336, Sahih Ibn Hibban 5/70}
Narrated from Ibn Umar RA. The Prophet peace be upon him when he would sit during the prayer meeting] had the hands on the knees diu tablets. The thumb of the right hand neighboring [martyrdom] finger was pointing out and put his left hand over the left knee. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1337}
Narrated from Ibn Umar RA. The Prophet peace be upon him to sit for the tashahhud, he kept his left hand on the left knee and right hand placed on his right knee. And [palm and hooks up Arabic] by the fifty-third of the fore-finger was pointed. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1338}
Hadisamuhe only by the finger has to be pointed out. Not to move a finger. But do not wag your fingers? There is no clear guidance in this regard. Another tradition that has been clearly mentioned. For example:
Umar narrated from Abdullah bin Zubair. When the Messenger of Allah used to Tashahhud, he was pointing the finger, but the finger was not naratei. {Sunan Kubra verse, Hadith No. -1193, Sunan Abu Dawood, Hadith No. -989, Imam Abu aoyana, Hadith No. -1594}
Comments about tradition muhaddisadera
1
After describing the tradition of Imam tumor David made no comment. It is also noted that the muhaddisadera, Imam Abu Dawud Hadith no comment to make on the means of the above-mentioned Hadith Sahih him.
II
Charter authentic Hadith Sahih of Imam Nawawi said. {Alakhulasa 1/428, alamajamu 3/454}
3
Abdul Haque Shibli said Muhaddis narrated in Sahih Hadith certificate. {249} alaahakamusa sugara
4
Narrated Ibn dakikula Eid said in proportion to the number of Hadith Sahih muhaddisadera statement. {Alailamama fees biahadisila Ruling 1/175}
5
Allama Ibn al-Hadith Sahih mulakkina Rh said. {Khulasatula Badrul Munir 1/139, alabadarula Munir 4/11, Masaabeeh and Tuhfatul Muhtaj 1/323}
6
Shaykh Haythmi Rh sikba narrator said that charters. {Mayamauja jaoyayida II / 143}
7
Asakalani Sahih Hadith of Ibn Hassan said. Takharije misakatula masabiha {1/411}
This is clearly proved by the Hadith, the Prophet Muhammad Tashahhud time was only pointing fingers, the fingers would have naratei.
Another idea is that by the external sound Hadith, the Prophet Muhammad was to move the fingers. Wael bin Lord narrated the Hadith from Sahih. Word is that tradition
Then he raised one finger, then I saw it, rock the boat. {Sunan Kubra verse, Hadith No. -1191, Sunan Daremi, Hadith No. -1357}
Comments about tradition muhaddisadera
Oyadeyi Sahih Hadith Allama Hassan says shows overwhelming. But it does sound saja. The issue is to move the finger. -389} {Ahadise muallaha
Muhaddisine the other doctors, such as Ibn Hajar asakalani, Imam Nawawi rah, rah al mulakkina sanadake authentic Hadith, among others, the traditionists.
Antithesis between the two hadith, what's the solution?
Allama Imam Bayhaqi narrated the Hadith says that the apparent reduction in the antithesis
By finger to move the goal, beckon. Naratei finger is not meant to be. If the money in the tradition of Abdullah bin Zubair R matches the description. {Bayahaki Sunan Kubra, Hadith No. 2615}
Imam Bayhaqi narrated that the solution to the apparent antithesis between the two traditions of the solution to end. That is going to understand that by Wael bin Monsieur R's tradition that the fingers move. This means, the finger was pointing to. Naratei was not the intention. If this interpretation Wail bin Abdullah bin Jubair said: Monsieur R's tradition and the tradition of the same meaning, which is the antithesis of that. {Bajalula mayahuda II / 127}
It argued that the normal, Tashahhud not have time to sit down and move your fingers. Find it Khushu prayer breaks. Moreover, if the finger is to disrupt the attention of the people to prayer. So in practice on authentic traditions in a clear and predictable act upon an interpretation of the finger on the Hadith sapeksya remain naratei would not be wise.
Hazrat Amir Abdullah bin Jubair narrated from his father that, he said, the Prophet peace be upon him to sit for the tashahhud reading, the right hand on the right thigh and put his left hand on left thigh. He was martyred by finger pointing. The median time to connect with the thumb and left palm [left] knee kept. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1336, Sahih Ibn Hibban 5/70}
Narrated from Ibn Umar RA. The Prophet peace be upon him when he would sit during the prayer meeting] had the hands on the knees diu tablets. The thumb of the right hand neighboring [martyrdom] finger was pointing out and put his left hand over the left knee. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1337}
Narrated from Ibn Umar RA. The Prophet peace be upon him to sit for the tashahhud, he kept his left hand on the left knee and right hand placed on his right knee. And [palm and hooks up Arabic] by the fifty-third of the fore-finger was pointed. {Sahih Muslim, Hadith No. -1338}
Hadisamuhe only by the finger has to be pointed out. Not to move a finger. But do not wag your fingers? There is no clear guidance in this regard. Another tradition that has been clearly mentioned. For example:
Umar narrated from Abdullah bin Zubair. When the Messenger of Allah used to Tashahhud, he was pointing the finger, but the finger was not naratei. {Sunan Kubra verse, Hadith No. -1193, Sunan Abu Dawood, Hadith No. -989, Imam Abu aoyana, Hadith No. -1594}
Comments about tradition muhaddisadera
1
After describing the tradition of Imam tumor David made no comment. It is also noted that the muhaddisadera, Imam Abu Dawud Hadith no comment to make on the means of the above-mentioned Hadith Sahih him.
II
Charter authentic Hadith Sahih of Imam Nawawi said. {Alakhulasa 1/428, alamajamu 3/454}
3
Abdul Haque Shibli said Muhaddis narrated in Sahih Hadith certificate. {249} alaahakamusa sugara
4
Narrated Ibn dakikula Eid said in proportion to the number of Hadith Sahih muhaddisadera statement. {Alailamama fees biahadisila Ruling 1/175}
5
Allama Ibn al-Hadith Sahih mulakkina Rh said. {Khulasatula Badrul Munir 1/139, alabadarula Munir 4/11, Masaabeeh and Tuhfatul Muhtaj 1/323}
6
Shaykh Haythmi Rh sikba narrator said that charters. {Mayamauja jaoyayida II / 143}
7
Asakalani Sahih Hadith of Ibn Hassan said. Takharije misakatula masabiha {1/411}
This is clearly proved by the Hadith, the Prophet Muhammad Tashahhud time was only pointing fingers, the fingers would have naratei.
Another idea is that by the external sound Hadith, the Prophet Muhammad was to move the fingers. Wael bin Lord narrated the Hadith from Sahih. Word is that tradition
Then he raised one finger, then I saw it, rock the boat. {Sunan Kubra verse, Hadith No. -1191, Sunan Daremi, Hadith No. -1357}
Comments about tradition muhaddisadera
Oyadeyi Sahih Hadith Allama Hassan says shows overwhelming. But it does sound saja. The issue is to move the finger. -389} {Ahadise muallaha
Muhaddisine the other doctors, such as Ibn Hajar asakalani, Imam Nawawi rah, rah al mulakkina sanadake authentic Hadith, among others, the traditionists.
Antithesis between the two hadith, what's the solution?
Allama Imam Bayhaqi narrated the Hadith says that the apparent reduction in the antithesis
By finger to move the goal, beckon. Naratei finger is not meant to be. If the money in the tradition of Abdullah bin Zubair R matches the description. {Bayahaki Sunan Kubra, Hadith No. 2615}
Imam Bayhaqi narrated that the solution to the apparent antithesis between the two traditions of the solution to end. That is going to understand that by Wael bin Monsieur R's tradition that the fingers move. This means, the finger was pointing to. Naratei was not the intention. If this interpretation Wail bin Abdullah bin Jubair said: Monsieur R's tradition and the tradition of the same meaning, which is the antithesis of that. {Bajalula mayahuda II / 127}
It argued that the normal, Tashahhud not have time to sit down and move your fingers. Find it Khushu prayer breaks. Moreover, if the finger is to disrupt the attention of the people to prayer. So in practice on authentic traditions in a clear and predictable act upon an interpretation of the finger on the Hadith sapeksya remain naratei would not be wise.
0 comments:
Post a Comment